Thursday, December 06, 2012

Hitler, Hindutva and Indian elite

My wife teaches French to tenth-grade students at a private school here in Mumbai. During one recent class, she asked these mostly upper-middle-class kids to complete the sentence “J'admire …” with the name of the historical figure they most admired.

To say she was disturbed by the results would be to understate her reaction. Of 25 students in the class, 9 picked Adolf Hitler, making him easily the highest vote-getter in this particular exercise; a certain Mohandas Gandhi was the choice of precisely one student. Discussing the idea of courage with other students once, my wife was startled by the contempt they had for Gandhi. “He was a coward!” they said. And as far back as 2002, the Times of India reported a survey that found that 17 percent of students in elite Indian colleges “favored Adolf Hitler as the kind of leader India ought to have.”

In a place where Gandhi becomes a coward, perhaps Hitler becomes a hero.

Still, why Hitler? “He was a fantastic orator,” said the 10th-grade kids. “He loved his country; he was a great patriot. He gave back to Germany a sense of pride they had lost after the Treaty of Versailles,” they said.

"And what about the millions he murdered?” asked my wife. “Oh, yes, that was bad,” said the kids. “But you know what, some of them were traitors.”

Admiring Hitler for his oratorical skills? Surreal enough. Add to that the easy condemnation of his millions of victims as traitors. Add to that the characterization of this man as a patriot. I mean, in a short dozen years, 

Hitler led Germany through a scarcely believable orgy of blood to utter shame and wholesale destruction. Even the mere thought of calling such a man a patriot profoundly corrupts—is violently antithetical to—the idea of patriotism.

But these are kids, you think, and kids say the darndest things. Except this is no easily written-off experience. The evidence is that Hitler has plenty of admirers in India, plenty of whom are by no means kids.

Consider Mein Kampf, Hitler’s autobiography. Reviled it might be in the much of the world, but Indians buy thousands of copies of it every month. As a recent paper in the journal EPW tells us (PDF), there are over a dozen Indian publishers who have editions of the book on the market. Jaico, for example, printed its 55th edition in 2010, claiming to have sold 100,000 copies in the previous seven years. (Contrast this to the 3,000 copies my own 2009 book, Roadrunner, has sold). In a country where 10,000 copies sold makes a book a bestseller, these are significant numbers.

And the approval goes beyond just sales. Mein Kampf is available for sale on, India’s Amazon. As I write this, 51 customers have rated the book; 35 of those gave it a five-star rating. What’s more, there’s a steady trickle of reports that say it has become a must-read for business-school students; a management guide much like Spencer Johnson’s Who Moved My Cheese or Edward de Bono’s Lateral Thinking. If this undistinguished artist could take an entire country with him, I imagine the reasoning goes, surely his book has some lessons for future captains of industry?

Much of Hitler’s Indian afterlife is the legacy of Bal Thackeray, chief of the Shiv Sena party who died on Nov. 17.
Thackeray freely, openly, and often admitted his admiration for Hitler, his book, the Nazis, and their methods. In 1993, for example, he gave an interview to Time magazine. “There is nothing wrong,” he said then, “if [Indian] Muslims are treated as Jews were in Nazi Germany.”

This interview came only months after the December 1992 and January 1993 riots in Mumbai, which left about a thousand Indians slaughtered, the majority of them Muslim. Thackeray was active right through those weeks, writing editorial after editorial in his party mouthpiece, “Saamna” (“Confrontation”) about how to “treat” Muslims.

On Dec. 9, 1992, for example, his editorial contained these lines: “Pakistan need not cross the borders and attack India. 250 million Muslims in India will stage an armed insurrection. They form one of Pakistan’s seven atomic bombs.”
A month later, on Jan. 8, 1993, there was this: “Muslims of Bhendi Bazar, Null Bazar, Dongri and Pydhonie, the areas [of Mumbai] we call Mini Pakistan … must be shot on the spot.”

There was plenty more too: much of it inspired by the failed artist who became Germany’s führer. After all, only weeks before the riots erupted, Thackeray said this about the führer’s famous autobiography: “If you take Mein Kampf and if you remove the word Jew and put in the word Muslim, that is what I believe in.”

With rhetoric like that, it’s no wonder the streets of my city saw the slaughter of 1992-93. It’s no wonder kids come to admire a mass-murderer, to rationalize away his massacres. It’s no wonder they cling to almost comically superficial ideas of courage and patriotism, in which a megalomaniac’s every ghastly crime is forgotten so long as we can pretend that he “loved” his country.

In his acclaimed 1997 book Hitler’s Willing Executioners, Daniel Goldhagen writes: “Hitler, in possession of great oratorical skills, was the [Nazi] Party’s most forceful public speaker. Like Hitler, the party from its earliest days was devoted to the destruction of … democracy [and to] most especially and relentlessly, anti-Semitism. … The Nazi Party became Hitler’s Party, obsessively anti-Semitic and apocalyptic in its rhetoric about its enemies.”

Do some substitutions in those sentences along the lines Thackeray wanted to do with Mein Kampf. Indeed, what you get is a more than adequate description of … no surprise, Thackeray himself.

Yes, it’s no wonder. Thackeray too was revered as an orator. Cremated, on Nov. 18, as a patriot.
Dilip D'Souza in The Daily Beast Here


Anonymous said...

Just want to say your article is as astonishing. The clarity in your post is simply nice and i can
suppose you are a professional on this subject. Well together with your permission allow me to
snatch your feed to keep up to date with coming near
near post. Thank you 1,000,000 and please carry
on the enjoyable work.
My web site affiliate programs

Anonymous said...

Hi! I could have sworn I've been to this website before but after checking through some of the post I realized it's new to me.
Nonetheless, I'm definitely glad I found it and I'll be bookmarking and checking back frequently!
Also visit my web blog ; penny Stocks list

Anonymous said...

I know this website offers quality based content and extra data, is there any other web page which offers
these things in quality?
Here is my web blog ; work from home baltimore

Anonymous said...

[url=]london purchase endep 25 mg online
[/url]amitriptyline get u high
buy amitriptyline online Melbourne
Sydney purchase endep 75 mg
buy endep online australia
order amitriptyline online no prescription

Anonymous said...

Fascinating. I wonder if you could comment on the how much pro -fascism there is compared to anti- British constitutionalism. is part of the appeal of Hitler related to the Bengali Famine and other British Policies?

Anonymous said...

The most exciting idea I had was hacking this game. ghd uk adobe illustrator cs5 ebook free download, Powered by Article Dashboard free astronomy software downloads, Powered by Article Dashboard equation, Powered by Article Dashboard course needed for career in finance, Powered by Article Dashboard chemistry lab, Powered by Article Dashboard aviation business development, Powered by Article Dashboard astronomy picture tool software, digit fasttrack to cryptology download, digit fast track 2012 free download, Powered by Article Dashboard research laboratory ghds Vintage handbags come in a number of designs and colours. Among other things, motivational speakers aid people to achieve something in business, develop their relationships, build up a positive manner, grow to be healthy, attain monetary prosperity, and have more excitement in life. ghd iv styler Emma was the proudest of this little bird embellishment that she picked out for her shirt.

Anonymous said...

Shop at Yours Elegantly and avoid the crowds at the stores, get unique products for yourself or as gifts at discounted sale pricing, coupled with great phone service and a free customer appreciation gift. ghd sale You want it to spread over the chicken and rice. The pieces have been on a global exhibition tour in Chile and Paris, and will be heading to Tokyo and China next before being auctioned in December.. Bottom line, shop smarter for purses, ! When you make the buy, we will ship the item within 2 organization days right after we have verified your payment. While we from active understand, sales channel designer handbags are usually developed in you the greatest leather-based thought to be to be able to humans and more typically absolutely nothing, turn up fitted working with a unencumbered with worthy of earth backpack on top of that.

Anonymous said...

We wonder if they be creating that ultra cool modern French manicure from the brand Fall couture show. north face jackets With an international roster of instructors, composed solely of industry professionals, the postgraduate program covers an in-depth survey of fashion design and production processes taught entirely in English. Spin 103.8's resident DJ's will be hosting the night.. Crocker Partners has appointed Cushman Wakefield Inc. ugg sale starting in the Mall Events Court.

Anonymous said...

[url=]clarithromycin online apotheke

Anonymous said...

Sustiva online
Efavirenz online
purchase Efavirenz 200 mg online
purchase Generic Sustiva 500 mg

Anonymous said...

Rubber Mulch - Keeping your Kids Safe in Playground Know What Your Mulching Options Are!

Take a look at my page
Here is my website - milwaukee tree nursery

Anonymous said...

Cheap Cell Phone Service with Page Plus Overall, I'd recommend considering Page Plus if you want to cut down on your cell phone cost. I use the $12 plan on my phone and find it is just what I need to make phone calls to my mom in California, keep up with my kid's schedules, be available
for emergencies, and text my friends. Page Plus won't work for everyone, but if you need an emergency phone, or a limited use phone which you could use more extensively if you needed to later, Page Plus can be a good choice. If you've had experience with Page Plus
or have another cheap cell phone service idea, please leave a comment and
share your experiences. Officials planned to release new evidence Friday proving that Dr.

Bruce Ivins, 62, mailed poison-laced letters to a
handful of politicians and newspaper outlets a finding the bureau advanced
during its preliminary investigation more than a year ago. Whether his replacement
will be another Islamic terrorist, such as al-Zawahiri, remains to be seen, although rumors are circulating in the press that he is a
likely candidate. Lulz Sec, a spin-off group of Anonymous, has taken responsibility for
attacks on Fox News and PBS, entertainment companies, including Sony and Nintendo, as well as local chapters of Infra Gard and Arizona law enforcement.
Visit my web page :: cell phone number lookup

Anonymous said...

Mulch Is Mother Natures Blanket Benefits From Using Recycled
Rubber Mulch

Take a look at my web-site
Also visit my blog ; trees for sale milwaukee

Anonymous said...

I'm focusing on company shopping website that uses joomla as its server (if which is correct word).. Someone uploaded files with spaces and apostrophes in the wrong folder and Joomla won't let me delete them within the usual way.

.. How can I delete these files (or edit the file names to enable them to then be deleted as normal)?
.. I posted this question on the Joomla forums but up to now no luck.

Review my website Transvaginalmesh411.Net
My web page - p

Anonymous said...

The best way to stop Firefox download window from appearing in

My weblog;
My blog post :: Paxil

Anonymous said...

The Origins Of Topsoil Mulching Lawn Mower - How To Mulch Your Grass For A Healthier
And Greener Lawn

Feel free to surf to my web site ...

Anonymous said...

It's very straightforward to find out any topic on web as compared to textbooks, as I found this paragraph at this web page.

Here is my web-site: dental insurance plans

Anonymous said...

My coder is trying to convince me to move to .net from PHP.
I have always disliked the idea because of the costs.
But he's tryiong none the less. I've been using Movable-type
on a number of websites for about a year and am concerned about switching to
another platform. I have heard very good things about blogengine.
net. Is there a way I can import all my wordpress content into it?

Any kind of help would be really appreciated!

Review my webpage - PBA Root Canal

Anonymous said...

I would like to thank you for the efforts you've put in penning this site. I really hope to see the same high-grade blog posts from you in the future as well. In truth, your creative writing abilities has inspired me to get my own, personal blog now ;)

my page; Www.Eletromaniacos.Com

Anonymous said...

How my article title to show up not your blog title during a search engine query
for any specific keyword?

Feel free to visit my weblog; vaginal mesh lawsuits
Also see my website: transvaginal mesh lawsuit

Anonymous said...

I am really enjoying the theme/design of your site.

Do you ever run into any browser compatibility issues? A few of my blog readers have complained
about my site not operating correctly in Explorer but looks great in Chrome.
Do you have any solutions to help fix this issue?

Here is my web page ...

Anonymous said...

Thank you for the good writeup. It in fact was a amusement account
it. Look advanced to far added agreeable from you! By the
way, how could we communicate?

Review my webpage ::

Anonymous said...

Everyone loves what you guys are up too.
Such clever work and coverage! Keep up the fantastic works guys
I've included you guys to my own blogroll.

Feel free to visit my website

Anonymous said...

Heya i am for the primary time here. I came across this board and I in
finding It truly useful & it helped me out a lot. I'm hoping to give something again and aid others like you aided me.

My page ::

Anonymous said...

Oh my goodness! Impressive article dude! Many thanks, However I am going through issues
with your RSS. I don't know the reason why I am unable to join it. Is there anybody having identical RSS problems? Anyone that knows the solution will you kindly respond? Thanx!!

Also visit my web blog -

Anonymous said...

I like all your stuff thanks for your post……… MSc Costume Design and Fashion Technology

Anonymous said...

I like all your stuff thanks for your post……… MSc Costume Design and Fashion Technology

SEO Moz said..., India's leading matrimonial portal site strive hard to provide you the perfect match with a touch of tradition from a wide array of community, caste, city and much more for the global Indian community you can find your life partner with help of makemylove
matrimonials sites indiaElite matrimonial services


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...